Anon (FoGT) 37^III

Sæll er sienn í milli
siðvendis kvikvenda
mána ranns af mönnum
mildingr, þá er barz hingað,
eða þá er djúp að djúpi
dorgtúns niða borgar
um hljóðraufar hávar
hátt samþykkið vátta.

{Sæll mildingr {ranns mána}} er sienn af mönnum í milli kvikvenda siðvendis, þá er barz hingað, eða þá er djúp {dorgtúns} vátta hátt samþykkið að djúpi um hávar hljóðraufar {borgar niða}.

{The blessed prince {of the house of the moon}} [SKY/HEAVEN > = God (= Christ)] was seen by men between animals of uprightness, when he was born into this world, or when the deep {of the fishing-line-field} [SEA] loudly bore witness of concord to the deep across the high sound-crevices {of the stronghold of the phases of the moon} [SKY/HEAVEN].

Mss: W(117) (FoGT)

Readings: [4] þá: sá W

Editions: Skj AII, 165, Skj BII, 183, Skald II, 95, NN §1410; SnE 1848-87, II, 236-7, III, 161-2, FoGT 1884, 145, 289-90, FoGT 2004, 52, 76, 150-2, FoGT 2014, 38-9, 129-31.

Context: Stanza 37 illustrates the figure the author of FoGT calls emophasis (homophesis). This glosar myrkan lvt með ǫðrum iammyrkvm lut eðr myrkara ‘explains an obscure thing by something equally obscure or more obscure’.

Notes: [All]: Stanza 37 is in dróttkvætt metre. — [All]: FoGT’s definition of homophesis is dependent on a similar one in the Doctrinale (Reichling 1893, 177, ll. 2627-9), where the examples come from the technical language of astrology. Here, however, the lengthy prose commentary that follows the stanza depends upon two excerpts from patristic writings, ‘the first a discussion attributed to Augustine of a verse from Habakkuk, and the second an interpretation of Ps. 41.8, “Abyssus abyssum inuocat in uoce cataractarum tuarum” ascribed to “leo pafi inn málsnialli”’ (D. McDougall 1988, 478). The obscurities of the two allusions are connected through the pivotal figure of Christ, whose birth as a human ushered in the new law; the first helmingr represents his birth in terms of two Old Testament prophecies, while the allegorical interpretation of the two abysses in the second connects the prophets of the Old Testament and their prophecies with the new law and the words of the apostles and church fathers. As McDougall (1988, 477-83) has shown, the Fourth Grammarian is likely to have derived his material from a text of the popular medieval homiliary of Paul the Deacon. — [1-4]: As both Meissner (1932, 98-101) and D. McDougall (1988) have shown, these lines depend upon the Old Latin version of Habakkuk III.2 In medio duorum animalium cognosceris ‘you will be recognised between two animals’. The interpretation of this text offered in FoGT is taken from a homiletic tract, Contra Judaeos, paganos, et Arianos sermo de symbolo, attributed to Augustine in the Middle Ages, but now included among the writings of Quodvultdeus, Bishop of Carthage 437-53 (D. McDougall 1988, 479). In this tract ‘Quodvultdeus seeks to confute the error of the Jews by summoning a series of Old Testament prophets as “witnesses” of the advent of Christ’ (D. McDougall loc. cit.). Habakkuk III.2 is there interpreted, together with Isiah I.3 Agnouit bos possessorem suum, et asinus praesepium domini sui ‘The ox knoweth his owner, and the ass his master’s crib’, as a prophecy of the Christ-child in the crib. In the prose of FoGT there is a further interpretation of the ox and the ass as representing the Jews and the Gentiles, an ‘exegetical commonplace’ to be found in a number of patristic commentaries (for the details, see D. McDougall 1988, 480 and nn.). — [1] er ‘was’: Lit. ‘is’. — [2] kvikvenda ‘animals’: The ms. reads kvikenda but this form is unmetrical, so eds (e.g. Skj B and Skald) have restored the second <v> to regularise the metre, and this practice is followed here. — [4] þá er ‘when’: An emendation from W’s sá er, first proposed by Björn Magnússon Ólsen (FoGT 1884, 289 n. 3), and adopted by all subsequent eds. — [4] hingað ‘into this world’: Lit. ‘hither’. — [5-8]: The interpretation of this helmingr follows those of Björn Magnússon Ólsen (FoGT 1884, 289-90) and Kock (NN §1410) rather than Finnur Jónsson (Skj B), who construes borgar niða ‘of the stronghold of the phases of the moon’ (l. 8) with að djúpi ‘to the deep’ (l. 5) rather than with um hávar hljóðraufar ‘across the high sound-crevices’ (l. 7), in order to provide one abyss in heaven, the other below it, but his interpretation fails to take account of the prose text’s commentary vnderdivp vatnanna kallar ꜳ̋ annat vnderdivp vm þær himinborvr sem katerakte kallaz ‘the abyss of the waters calls to the other abyss across those heaven-holes that are called cataracts’. — [5-8]: The stanza’s second helmingr depends upon the second patristic example mentioned in the first Note to [All] above, Ps. XLI. 8 Abyssus abyssum inuocat, in uoce cataractarum tuarum ‘Deep calleth unto deep at the noise of thy waterspouts’. The prose gloss attributes its interpretation of Ps. XLI.8 to leo paví hinn mꜳl sníálle ‘Pope Leo the eloquent’, probably Leo the Great. McDougall (1988, 481) proposed this might be a reference to the sixtieth tractate of Pope Leo, also available in the homiliary of Paul the Deacon. The prose gloss proposes an allegorical reading of the voice of the two vatnadjúp ‘abysses’, the one above the heavens, the other below it, on several levels, including their identification with the old and new laws and the teachings of prophets and apostles. McDougall (loc. cit.) adduces several conventional examples of such parallels. — [8] vátta ‘bore witness’: Lit. ‘bears witness’. This verb is both pl. and pres. tense, where one would expect the pret. váttuðu. Kock (NN §1410) draws attention to a similar use of pres. tense where a pret. would be expected in st. 47/4 (and cf. er in l. 1 above’). The pl. usage with a sg. subject (djúp) can probably be explained, as Björn Magnússon Ólsen (FoGT 1884, 290 n. 5) has suggested, because the poet is thinking of two mighty abysses rather than one (and djúp n. can be either sg. or pl.). In the prose the verb kalla is also pl. with a sg. subject. Björn emended vátta to the 3rd pers. sg. pres. tense váttar.

References

1. Bibliography
2. Skj B = Finnur Jónsson, ed. 1912-15b. Den norsk-islandske skjaldedigtning. B: Rettet tekst. 2 vols. Copenhagen: Villadsen & Christensen. Rpt. 1973. Copenhagen: Rosenkilde & Bagger.
3. SnE 1848-87 = Snorri Sturluson. 1848-87. Edda Snorra Sturlusonar: Edda Snorronis Sturlaei. Ed. Jón Sigurðsson et al. 3 vols. Copenhagen: Legatum Arnamagnaeanum. Rpt. Osnabrück: Zeller, 1966.
4. Skald = Kock, Ernst Albin, ed. 1946-50. Den norsk-isländska skaldediktningen. 2 vols. Lund: Gleerup.
5. NN = Kock, Ernst Albin. 1923-44. Notationes Norrœnæ: Anteckningar till Edda och skaldediktning. Lunds Universitets årsskrift new ser. 1. 28 vols. Lund: Gleerup.
6. FoGT 1884 = Björn Magnússon Ólsen, ed. 1884. Den tredje og fjærde grammatiske afhandling i Snorres Edda tilligemed de grammatiske afhandlingers prolog og to andre tillæg. SUGNL 12. Copenhagen: Knudtzon.
7. FoGT 2004 = Longo, Michele, ed. [2004]. ‘Il Quarto Trattato Grammaticale Islandese: Testo, Traduzione e Commento’. Dottorato di Ricerca in ‘Linguistica Sincronica e Diacronica’ (XV Ciclo). Palermo: Università degli Studi di Palermo, Facoltà di Lettere e Filosofia.
8. McDougall, David. 1988. ‘“Pseudo-Augustinian” Passages in “Jóns saga baptista 2” and the “Fourth Grammatical Treatise”’. Traditio 44, 463-83.
9. Meissner, Rudolf. 1932. ‘Zwei Prophetenzitate in der 4. Gramm. Abhandlung der Snorra Edda’. ZDA 69, 97-106.
10. Reichling, Dietrich, ed. 1893. Das Doctrinale des Alexander de Villa-Dei. Monumenta Germaniae paedagogica 12. Berlin: A. Hofmann & Comp. Rpt. 1974. Burt Franklin Research and Source Works Series, Studies in the History of Education 11. New York: Burt Franklin.
11. FoGT 2014 = Clunies Ross, Margaret and Jonas Wellendorf, eds. 2014. The Fourth Grammatical Treatise. University College London: Viking Society for Northern Research.
12. Internal references
13. (forthcoming), ‘ Unattributed, The Fourth Grammatical Treatise’ in Kari Ellen Gade and Edith Marold (eds), Poetry from Treatises on Poetics. Skaldic Poetry of the Scandinavian Middle Ages 3. Turnhout: Brepols, p. . <https://skaldic.org/m.php?p=text&i=34> (accessed 25 April 2024)
14. Not published: do not cite (Run^VI)